If even this lady–haver of amazing eyebrows–needs three brow products, we should all take note. I am also on a three brow product regime lately.
Spooli–that thing you brush your brows with. It is essential for making any brow product (powder, pencil, gel) look natural. Word on the street is that you can just buy a stand alone one, but I use the one on the end of my Anastasia Brow Wiz (Try Medium Brown–the ashiest of all the colors–unless you are a true brunette or a true red head).
Pencil–I love the Blonde version of the one this pretty lady is using (Revlon Brow Fantasy), but the pencil lasts me a month, so you might as well spend the money for the Anastasia. Also the gel side of the Brow Fantasy is pants.
Gel–For true wild eyebrow hair taming you essentially need a mascara for your brows. My parent who has crazy eyebrow hairs swears by MAC for this level of hold. Word on the Beauty Youtubes is that the new L’Oreal Brow Stylist gel also holds like crunchy, but effective glue.
For medium crazy brow hairs the Anastasia Brow Gel, the Benefit Gimme Brow, and the Maybelline Brow Drama, and the Bobbi Brown Brow Gel are great and have the added benefit of working as a one step brow solution on busy days. Only the Anastasia has a broad color range out of all these, but both shades of the Benefit are pretty ashy (in Brow Culture ASHY is close to holiness).
And one more thing: STOP PLUCKING/WAXING YOUR BROWS. Your eye caterpillars are your greatest asset.